Interview

Inside America's Retro Gaming Market: 15 Years of Gamers Inc Orlando

From rare collections and counterfeit cartridges to nostalgia, rising prices, and a new generation of collectors: Anthony Ventura shares his perspective on America's retro gaming market through his experience at Gamers Inc Orlando.

Interior of Gamers Inc Orlando, showing its counter, green illuminated sign, and displays of video games and consoles.

Inside America's Retro Gaming Market: 15 Years of Gamers Inc Orlando

Subtitle: From rare collections and counterfeit cartridges to nostalgia, rising prices, and a new generation of collectors: Anthony Ventura shares his perspective on America's retro gaming market through his experience at Gamers Inc Orlando.

A ten-year-old boy looking for an original PlayStation to play Final Fantasy IX. A collector returning to a store with more than a thousand games, including Sega Saturn rarities and Atari Jaguar consoles. These are just two of the stories that can unfold behind the counter of an American retro video game store.

Founded in 2010 in Orlando, Florida, Gamers Inc Orlando specializes in buying, selling, and trading video games, consoles, and collectibles. Alongside its physical store, the company also operates the online shop Gamers Go Retro. Established by former employees of the Play N Trade chain, the business has experienced more than fifteen years of changes in the gaming market.

During that time, collecting video games has evolved from a relatively niche hobby into a much broader phenomenon, accompanied by growing demand and, in many cases, dramatically rising prices. The audience has changed, too. Alongside enthusiasts who grew up with consoles from the 1980s and 1990s, a new generation is discovering classic games through the internet and seeking out the original hardware to experience them.

To explore how this world has evolved in the United States, we spoke with Anthony Ventura, Operations Manager at Gamers Inc Orlando, about the store's history, collecting trends, counterfeit games, and some of the most remarkable encounters he has experienced over the years.

His stories offer a glimpse into the American retro gaming scene, where nostalgia, business, and genuine passion continue to coexist, sometimes with a few contradictions along the way.

The Origins and Evolution of Retro Gaming

Let's start at the beginning. How did Gamers Inc Orlando come to life in 2010? What inspired the opening of the store, and what was the collecting scene like in Orlando back then?

Gamers Inc Orlando has gone through a couple different life cycles. Prior to 2010, our location used to be a Play N Trade, which eventually went under. As Play N Trade went under, the employees who worked there decided to come together and buy the store inventory. That is how Gamers Inc Orlando was founded.

I came into the fray years later to find what was already an incredible game store with an incredible reputation. I learned about the Gamers Inc standard, the very high standard of measures we continue to employ to preserve retro gaming for everyone. The philosophy behind Gamers Inc is not to just sell games, it is to go through the lengths required to preserve each game that we buy through measures we take to clean, test, and restore all games and consoles as if they were still in production.

Collecting games back in 2010 was a more niche hobby. Game values had not fully skyrocketed, and you could still find games like Pokemon Emerald complete-in-box for less than $300, compared to the prices now which would regularly exceed $800. To put it in perspective, in 2010, the latest generation of game consoles were the Xbox 360 and the PlayStation 3, widely considered a golden age in the history of gaming.

Looking at the changes in the industry since 2010, what would you say has been the biggest transformation in the American retro gaming market? Were there particular moments when you noticed things beginning to change?

The pandemic of 2020 really shook up the game market. More people who were quarantined at home wanted to root out their old consoles and enjoy the games they played growing up. It was a tough time for most of the world, and many sought the comfort of nostalgia.

In 2020, the demand for retro games, which are innately finite, grew tremendously, and more content creators emerged, highlighting the retro gaming world with content surrounding gameplay and nostalgia. This whirlwind combination turned a quiet hobby into an in-demand business.

Gamers Inc survived the local business restrictions by selling on eBay, and prices for games and consoles sharply rose. Suddenly, everyone wanted a GameCube again, everyone wanted the original Halo series, and everyone wanted to become a collector.

Not much has changed since then, as game prices continue to reflect their rarity, and are in a more open scope. I get customers all of the time, from all over the world, who visit shops like ours just to grow their collection. The hobby has a lot of range too, with kids as young as 7 asking for consoles three times their own age, and middle-aged collectors who are looking for holy grails.

How has your typical customer evolved over the years? Are you still seeing mostly nostalgic adults returning to the games of their childhood, or are younger generations discovering and collecting systems that existed long before they were born?

The age range continues to shock me. We have our regulars, generally between 26-36, who consistently come in for their 90s and early 2000s fix.

However, every day I see customers that are still in elementary school asking for consoles like GameBoy Advances, with genuine excitement and knowledge of what they are getting into. Kids are paying attention to the content online, as they are finding out about quality games which came before them.

I recently had a young customer no older than 10 who was looking for a PlayStation 1, and he specifically wanted to play Final Fantasy IX, one of the great games of its time. As I spent time informing him about the console, he knew all the ins and outs already, as he had been watching creators like Scott The Woz, do deep dives on games.

What strikes me is that not only were these games way before his time, but he specifically wanted to experience the original way of playing the game on its original hardware. Pretty amazing to see the hobby transcend age.

Glass display cabinet featuring Nintendo Game Boy, Game Boy Advance, Sony PSP, and PS Vita handheld consoles.
A selection of handheld consoles at Gamers Inc Orlando. According to Anthony Ventura, younger players are increasingly interested in systems from earlier generations.

Games, Consoles, and Collecting Trends

Which consoles and gaming generations are currently attracting the most interest among your customers? Have any systems experienced a surprising resurgence in popularity?

The mainstays are always PlayStation 2 and GameCube. That generation of early 2000s gamers all want to relive their classics, and for good reason.

GameCube has some of the best first-party Nintendo games around like WindWaker, Twilight Princess, Pikmin, Super Smash Bros. Melee, and so many more.

Alternatively, PlayStation 2 is an absolute beast, and it dominated the console market at the time with robust multimedia features, and vast library or edgier games like Resident Evil, Silent Hill, and Grand Theft Auto.

A recent surge in demand for PSP, 3DS, Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3 have popped up at our store over the last year. If I put out 20 refurbished PSP consoles in the cases, within less than two weeks they are all gone.

Clearly the generations are catching up with their ability to spend extra money on games. Xbox 360 games are in high demand, especially games like Left4Dead, and the PlayStation 3 online shop is due to shutdown in 2027, leaving many exclusive PS3 titles stranded and playable only on physical hardware.

Retro game prices have become a major topic among collectors. Based on your experience, which games or consoles have seen the most dramatic changes in value? Can you share a few examples that particularly surprised you?

Currently, The PS3 and Xbox 360 era is going through a bit of a renaissance. The online shop is shutting down in 2027, leaving many physical games only playable on PS3 hardware.

The prices are skyrocketing much earlier on than I anticipated, with games like Spider-Man: Web Of Shadows quickly going from an $80 average price to over $200.

Xbox 360 games do not demand as much value, as Sony console games are generally more sought after, but their demand is still rising. We are currently selling through Xbox 360 inventory at a very fast rate, and their prices are up on the market by as much as 20%.

Editor's note: Sony announced that the PlayStation Store on PS3 and PS Vita will stop allowing new purchases in the United States and most other markets in July 2027. Previously purchased content will remain available for download for the foreseeable future. The store's closure therefore does not automatically mean that players will lose access to their existing digital libraries. Source: PlayStation Blog.

Glass cabinet displaying collectible Pokémon, PlayStation, Sega Genesis, and Saturn games at Gamers Inc Orlando.
Collectible video games from different generations on display at Gamers Inc Orlando. Rarity, condition, and collector demand all influence market prices.

Do you feel that collecting has changed from a passion primarily driven by playing games into something increasingly influenced by investment, rarity, sealed copies and professional grading? Or is that perception exaggerated?

I would say that the retro game market is not as heavily influenced by this as the adjacent TCG market is. Getting games graded for sale is not as much of a necessity as it is in the TCG market, as there are not as many consumers paying graded values for video games.

The thing about most collectors I know that spend tens of thousands of dollars every year on games is that they still want to be able to play them. When a game is sealed and graded, you do not want to open it or you will lose its graded value, so it is a shelf piece.

However, even games as expensive as Kuon, Silent Hill 3, Clay Fighters Sculptor’s are all still playable even in their sought-after conditions, such as “CIB,” or “Complete-In-Box.” CIB values are more affected by collector consumption.

I have a friend and longtime customer who always says, “CIB or its not for me,” so there are elements of that collector market in this hobby, but it doesn’t make it completely unattainable for the average gamers the same way that buying new Pokemon card products are almost completely unattainable due to scalpers.

Counterfeits and Authenticity

Counterfeit cartridges, reproduction packaging and misleading listings are becoming a concern for collectors. How frequently do you encounter these issues in your business, and which platforms or games seem particularly affected?

The most common counterfeit game comes in the form of a cartridge-based game, such as GameBoy Advance Pokemon games. My team is well-versed on what to look for when spotting fakes.

Unfortunately for the seller, a lot of times they bring me a mixed bag of games to sort through, inspect, and buy, and may have the odd Pokemon game or two that were reproductions which they bought years ago, deceitfully sold to them as authentic.

So, most of our interactions with that are completely educational. We spend the time to show our customers what to look for when spotting a fake game, and more often than not they are very shocked when they realize someone online scammed them, and they thought they were going to get a good value in cash for their Pokemon game.

Counterfeiting is everywhere, but most prevalent in games such as N64, GameBoy Color, GameBoy advance, Super Nintendo, and DS cartridges. I always take the time to show my customers what to look for when spotting authentic games and avoid scams on eBay and other selling platforms.

When someone brings a potentially valuable game into your store, how do you determine whether it's authentic? What practical warning signs should collectors look for before purchasing expensive retro games?

Depending on the type of game, we have many measures to ensure authenticity. For practicality, collectors should look out cartridge-based games such as GameBoy Advance games, which should have a Nintendo serialized motherboard, a double-digit manufacturer’s impression on the right side of the label, signs of wear and use, and sometimes even a battery on the inside, which can be seen from without taking the cartridge apart in some cases like Pokemon Emerald, for example.

For discs, we look for the manufacturer’s security inner ring on the disc with the proper holographic effect and official branding. We do also test the games to ensure proper gameplay and no evidence of rom copies or disc burning.

Life Behind the Counter

Throughout the store's more than fifteen years in business, the team must have encountered some extraordinary games, collections, and people. Is there a particular discovery, trade-in, or customer experience that you'll never forget?

There are so many I can list, so this is a hard decision. My favorite part of my job is trades, and engaging with the sellers. I have met so many wonderful people during trade processing, and many of those interactions led to more incredible trade finds.

I had a seller come in this year with around thirty games, nothing too rare, just good quality games. I had such a good time working with him on the trade, and he was very happy with our offer, so much so in fact, that he came back with over a thousand games to trade in.

He described the games sold to me as his “duplicates,” which is completely shocking given the fact that he sold me incredibly collectible games like the Silent Hill series, Magic Knight Rayearth, Bomberman Saturn, the entire Clock Tower Series, and the most pristine set of complete-in-box Atari Jaguar consoles the world has probably ever seen since the launch of the Jaguar.

I also have another customer who sells things to me occasionally who used to be a store manager of an EB Games location back in the day. He sold me just about every Working Designs game ever in the most pristine condition, including every pre-order bonus that he had access to back then since he was working at EB Games.

From sealed promotional material, official store displays for games, pre-order bonuses, and marketing material directly from developers to an amazing assortment of rare games, I was always amazed by the games he brought me.

Regarding fun trades and rare items, I always tell my team, “You never know who or what is going to come through those doors.”

Atari Jaguar cartridges for Rayman, Doom, and Raiden held in front of a colorful wall of video games.
Rayman, Doom, and Raiden for Atari Jaguar. Ventura recalls a remarkable trade-in that included an exceptional collection of boxed Jaguar consoles.

In an age dominated by digital distribution and online marketplaces, what can an independent physical video game store offer that an online retailer simply cannot? And what are the biggest challenges involved in keeping such a business alive today?

It is quite simple, stores like Gamers Inc can offer something that digital marketplaces could never and refuse to offer to their customers: ownership.

Digital games are rental agreements, I should know, I have paid full price for seven AAA games on the PlayStation store, and over time each license was plucked from me as if I never even paid for it.

You come to Gamers Inc or visit GamersGoRetro.com, the game you buy is the game you own, and you can keep it or sell it whenever you want. Aside from ownership, you do not need a subscription to play Super Mario 64, you just buy the console and the game, and you get the full experience.

We live in a day in age where it is almost completely expected that the next AAA game from a AAA studio to come out will be buggy, half-baked, and completely out of touch with its audience. Ubisoft, 343 Studios, Activision, Bungie - all these companies have overpromised and underdelivered for years and have made decisions that are completely out of touch with their own fan base!

So, when you pick up a fully refurbished PlayStation 2, the best-selling console worldwide, with an impressive roster of thousands of original and creative games, you do not need to worry about the internet being on or having to pay a subscription to enjoy a quality game like Resident Evil Outbreak.

It is no wonder that gamers are supporting more indie studios for new releases because the quality of AAA games has diminished, and the baked-in pay to win mechanics have made gamers weary of buying the next $79.99 game that is supposed to be something completely different from what it turns out to be.

Collector’s editions used to mean something too. You would receive the game, a special case, stickers, necklaces, figures, statues, maps, and all manner of bonuses – now you receive a digital skin pack.

In terms of challenges, game stores need to stop buying games and then slapping them on the shelves with GameStop stickers, scratched discs, dirty pins, and filth all over them. I find it distressing when I walk into a supposed “retro game store,” and everything is disorganized, the games are dirty and it looks and feels like I am buying “buyer beware” products from a flea market.

Gamers Inc has been working to preserve retro gaming for the next generation, that means consoles get cleaned inside and out, refurbished with new lasers or capacitor fixes, discs are resurfaced and shined, game cases do not have 20-year-old EB Games stickers on them, and cartridge pins get completely stripped clean, all backed by our 90-day warranty.

Offer customers real value for their purchase.

Looking Ahead

Looking at the next five or ten years, where do you think retro gaming and physical game collecting are heading? Which trends do you believe will shape the market?

As current-generation platforms pivot to strictly digital media, we are going to see a sharp increase in prices over time.

Gradually, I can see just about every physical game start to see their demand increase among the collectors and those who want to explore the vast libraries of games that came before.

We are going to see the games that are already high in price continue to increase in value. It is already happening to PlayStation 3, as the online shop for it shuts down in 2027, its games are steadily on the rise both in price and in demand.

This will happen across all generations of consoles. Physical media won’t be going anywhere on our watch.

Finally, if someone were walking into Gamers Inc Orlando today, eager to start their very first retro video game collection, what advice would you give them?

I always implore people I meet to consider exploring the games of yesterday. Nowadays, the market is dominated by a few AAA studios with huge budgets, but often we have seen their games diminish in terms of quality and creativity.

However, if you are an RPG fan, go back and play PlayStation RPG games, widely considered one of the most creative and colorful generations of RPG games ever to come out. Final Fantasy games went to the next level on PS1.

When you get a retro console from us, you have access to an enormous library of physical games that you can own, and you will find that developers were finding innovative ways to explore the capability of the hardware they made games for.

PlayStation 2 alone has enough games for a lifetime, it’s the console that wrote the book on the Survival Horror genre and gave rise to many familiar names we know today such as God Of War, Sly Cooper, Jak and Daxter, and wildly popularized giants in the industry like Grand Theft Auto.

So, whether you are a Nintendo fan, Sega fan, an XBOX fan, whether you love shooters, JRPG styles, RTS games, Platformers, or racing games, there is something for everyone to discover and fall in love with on retro hardware.

So, do your research, watch some gameplay videos, and find the games you never knew you loved on the consoles that started it all.

Learn more: Gamers Go Retro – Official Website

Interview with Anthony Ventura, Operations Manager at Gamers Inc Orlando. Photographs courtesy of Gamers Inc Orlando.

0 memories

Reader memories

Comment on the article and join the discussion.

Comment rules

Loading comments...